Judge remands Portuguese ex-PM in custody in fraud case

A Portuguese judge on Monday (Nov 24) ordered former Socialist prime minister Jose Socrates to be remanded in custody on suspicion of tax evasion and money laundering.

• PHOTOS

LISBON: A Portuguese judge on Monday (Nov 24) ordered former Socialist prime minister Jose Socrates to be remanded in custody on suspicion of tax evasion and money laundering.

Socrates, 57, has been held in detention since his shock arrest on Friday at Lisbon airport after arriving on a flight from Paris. After lengthy questioning on Monday in connection with the corruption probe, a judge decided that the ex-premier should be kept in preventative detention. Socrates was placed under formal investigation "for tax evasion, corruption and money laundering", according to the judge's statement read out to reporters.

The ex-premier's attorney, Joao Araujo, called the decision "deeply unjust and unjustified" and vowed to appeal. His personal chauffeur Joao Perna and businessman Carlos Santos were also held in custody. Luis Montenegro, parliamentary leader of the ruling Social Democrats (PSD) said that the country's image had been tarnished "both internally and abroad by what has gone on in recent days."

The centre-right government has remained discreet about the case. Prime Minister Pedro Passos Coelho said on Sunday it "pertains to the law and not politics," adding "Portugal has strong institutions that work."

Socrates' arrest was the latest bombshell in Portuguese politics, coming hard on the heels of another scandal that cost interior minister Miguel Macedo his job. A series of searches have been carried out at businesses and Socrates' residence in Lisbon.

According to Portuguese media reports, state-owned bank Caixa Geral de Depositos raised the alarm. Investigators have been looking into transfers involving the former Socialist leader's account in comparison with earnings he has reported to tax authorities.

Particular attention is said to have been given to an apartment in Paris estimated at nearly €3 million (US$3.7 million). Socrates lived there in 2012 while studying philosophy in the French capital. "I have no money or accounts abroad. I have always lived off the income from my own job," Socrates assured in July, when he was questioned by the press over another money laundering case.

The case is certainly an unwelcome sideshow for Lisbon mayor Antonio Costa, a former interior minister under Socrates and the Socialist party's new secretary general. So far Costa has refused to distance himself from Socrates, saying that the Socialist party "does not adopt Stalinist practices of getting rid of photos" of former leaders.

A colourful character, Socrates announced his resignation as prime minister in March 2011, after parliament rejected an austerity budget. Shortly afterwards the country received a €78 billion bailout package from the European Union and the International Monetary Fund in exchange for a rigorous programme of fiscal discipline which came to an end in May. Socrates was prime minister between 2005 and 2011, with his tenure particularly marked by the financial crisis that badly hit the country. 

- AFP/nd

Portugal ex-PM Jose Socrates to be held amid corruption probe

25 November 2014 Last updated at 00:47 GMT

The decision to detain Jose Socrates sent shockwaves through Portuguese politics

Portugal's former centre-left prime minister, Jose Socrates, has been remanded in custody on preliminary charges of corruption and tax fraud.

Mr Socrates, 57, was detained on his return from Paris on Friday and has already spent three nights in jail.

The judge delivered the decision after investigators looked into suspicious money transfers and banking operations.

Mr Socrates, who denies any wrongdoing, is being investigated alongside his driver, a close friend, and a lawyer.

The former prime minister was in office from 2005 to 2011. His lawyer, Joao Araujo, told reporters on Monday that his client would appeal against the decision.

Under the Portuguese system, formal charges only come at the end of an investigation which could last up to eight months, says the BBC's Alison Roberts in Lisbon.

Portuguese politics was already reeling after the resignation of Interior Minister Miguel Macedo in the wake of a separate corruption inquiry linked to the allocation of residence permits.

Portugal in shock - by Alison Roberts, BBC News, Lisbon

Jose Socrates' detention has sent shockwaves through the political system. Reports purporting to provide details of the investigation - which is covered by judicial secrecy - have swirled since Friday night, when the news broke. They focus on Mr Socrates' supposedly lavish lifestyle in Paris, where he moved after stepping down in 2011.

In past interviews, he has denied anything untoward about his finances.

Antonio Costa, elected Socialist leader on Saturday, said everyone was in shock over Mr Socrates' detention

His detention - on arrival at Lisbon airport, rather than at his flat, and with photographers present - prompted some prominent Socialists to argue it was to divert attention from suspicions of corruption in the right-of-centre government's "golden visa" programme, which fast-tracks residence for foreign investors.

The Socialists' newly elected leader, Antonio Costa, a minister under Mr Socrates, was until now expected to sweep to victory in next year's general election following years of austerity. He is conscious of the perils of the situation.

Portugal's ex-PM Jose Socrates

Because the case surrounding Mr Socrates comes under judicial secrecy, few details have been confirmed.

It is unclear whether the inquiry relates to his time in office. However, Portuguese media has reported allegations that his driver Joao Perna made a number of trips transporting cash to Paris, where Mr Socrates has been working in a new role at a pharmaceutical company.

Current Prime Minister Pedro Passos Coelho gave his backing to the country's "strong institutions"

One of Mr Socrates' long-time friends, Carlos Santos Silva, is being questioned along with lawyer Goncalo Trindade Ferreira.

Two of the suspects are also being held on remand, while a fourth has been barred from foreign travel.

Centre-right Prime Minister Pedro Passos Coelho said the case involved law rather than politics, adding that "Portugal has strong institutions that work".

But the investigation has rocked Mr Socrates' Socialists, now led by Lisbon Mayor Antonio Costa who was elected as secretary-general of the party on Saturday.

Mr Socrates resigned in 2011 in the midst of Portugal's mounting debt crisis. The Socialists are currently leading in opinion polls and Mr Costa said on Saturday that "we mustn't let personal feelings of solidarity and friendship impede the political action of the (party)".

The European Parliament might endorse the breakup of Google

Updated by Timothy B. Lee on November 24, 2014, 2:40 p.m. ET 

PATRICK HERTZOG/AFP/Getty Images

• On Friday, the Financial Times reported that the European Parliament is on the verge of voting on a resolution that could call for legal against action Google for anticompetitive behavior.
• In a vote expected to occur on Thursday, the European Parliament may endorse forcing Google to spin off its lucrative search engine into a separate company.
• However, the European Parliament doesn't have the power to directly break up companies, and one legal scholar tells me that Google is in no danger of actually being broken up.

Why are European officials investigating Google?

Google has been under scrutiny from European regulators since at least 2010. That's when the European Commission announced it was launching an investigation of the search giant's business practices.

To prove that a company has broken competition laws, European regulators must prove that a company has a dominant position in the market, and that it has abused its dominance. Mark Patterson, an antitrust expert at Fordham University, says that Google clearly has a dominant position in the search business. The question is whether the company has abused that dominance.

European officials are scrutinizing two specific aspects of Google's business to see if the company has crossed any legal lines. One is the company's search results. If Google was deliberately downranking sites it viewed as a competitive threat from search results, that could run afoul of the law.

Second, European regulators are examining Google's business practices in the advertising market. They want to see if Google imposed exclusivity obligations on its advertising partners that would make it difficult for smaller advertising networks to gain traction.

Google CEO Larry Page (Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

Will Google CEO Larry Page be losing sleep over Thursday's vote by the European Parliament?

Not really.

According to the FT, "executives at the company are understood to be furious at the political nature of the motion and only became aware of the document in the past couple of days." However, the reality is that the European Parliament doesn't have the power to order companies broken up. Rather, a vote in favor of the resolution would merely put pressure on the European Commission — the supranational organization's executive branch — to take a hard line in its ongoing negotiations with Google.

For Google to actually get broken up, the EC would first need to take Google to court alleging violation of European competition laws. The EC would then have to win the case and convince the courts that a breakup was the appropriate remedy.

"I can't believe that would happen," Patterson told me on Monday. "I don't think there have been cases of anyone being broken up in years."

Patterson says that "there's never been a smoking gun" showing that Google has abused its dominance in the search or advertising markets to harm competitors. He notes that the Federal Trade Commission, which enforces antitrust law in the United States, closed a similar investigation last year. The FTC concluded that Google had offered plausible pro-competitive and pro-consumer explanations for its business decisions.

So there's a good chance the European Commission will decide not to formally charge Google with violating competition laws. And even if the EC does decide to bring a case, it's far from certain the agency will win.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel (RONNY HARTMANN/AFP/Getty Images)

What's driving anti-Google sentiment in the European Parliament?

While this week's vote is officially about violations of antitrust law, there are several factors that have led European legislators to be more skeptical about Google.

One factor is privacy. European privacy law is stricter than the laws that prevail in the United States. And because Google amasses more information about people than almost anyone else, the company has often been a target of European privacy advocates.

For example, earlier this year Google was forced to comply with European regulations governing the "right to be forgotten." These regulations give European citizens the right to demand, under certain circumstances, that old and potentially embarrassing information about them be removed from Google's search results.

Some Europeans also object to the way Google uses copyrighted material. For example, Google News displays "snippets" of content from European news organizations. While this kind of use is generally believed to be permitted under the American doctrine of fair use, the practice is more controversial in the Old World. Some European countries have tried to force Google to pay for the inclusion of snippets in its news search results.

Finally, some have pointed to American surveillance policy as a source of trans-Atlantic friction. One writer notes that the current campaign against Google is supported by Germans who are allied with German Chancellor Angela Merkel. Merkel was furious last year when she learned that the US government had been tapping her phone. While that controversy isn't directly relevant to the EC's current investigation, it certainly may have colored the views of European politicians who see Google as excessively close to the American government.

If Google doesn't get broken up, how else could the EC's investigation end?

Negotiations between Google and the European Commission have been going on for several years. Indeed, the company has already made settlement offers to the commission three times. In Google's most recent offer, announced in February, Google would have reserved space in its search results to prominently feature competitors' offerings.

But the commission rejected that offer in September, sending the two sides back to the negotiating table.

At this point, the case could end in one of three ways. Theoretically the EC could simply decide to drop the case. But Patterson says that's unlikely because it would be too embarrassing to concede defeat after four years of high-profile negotiations.

It's also possible that the EC will decide that Google isn't being reasonable and will start a formal case against the company. That could lead to Google's breakup, but it could also lead to lesser punishments such as paying a fine and being required to change business practices.

Finally, Google could make a fourth settlement offer, on terms the EC was willing to accept.

If the European Parliament endorses action against Google, it will increase pressure on European regulators to take the company to court. But going to court is a big gamble, since the EC could lose and get no concessions at all. So even if the European Parliament endorses a tough stance against Google, there's no guarantee the EC will follow its recommendations.

JARDIM TROPICAL MONTE PALACE (com vista aérea)

THIS WONDERFUL GARDEN IS SET JUST BEHIND MY HOUSE...''TROPICAL GARDEN, MONTE PALE'', IT BELONGS TO A MILLIONAIRE '' JOE BERARDO''... A BEAUTIFUL PLACE TO VISIT, WHILE AT MADEIRA ISLAND, (RESERVE A FEW HOURS TO SPEND IN THIS MAGICAL GARDEN )...

Portuguese ex-PM returns before judge in tax fraud case

AFP

November 23, 2014, 8:05 pm

Portuguese ex-PM returns before judge in tax fraud case

Lisbon (AFP) - Portugal's former Socialist prime minister Jose Socrates returned before a magistrate on Sunday after spending a second night in custody following his shock arrest as part of an inquiry into tax fraud, corruption and money laundering.

Socrates, 57, who has been held since his arrest Friday as he arrived at Lisbon airport on a flight from Paris, made a first appearance in court on Saturday to answer questions about suspicious money transfers and banking operations.

The arrest was the latest bombshell in Portuguese politics, coming hard on the heels of another scandal that cost Interior Minister Miguel Macedo his job.

Macedo resigned on November 16 after several senior government officials were arrested as part of a probe into money laundering and influence-peddling around so-called "golden visas".

"It's a sad day for Portugal and the Portuguese," commented conservative former prime minister Pedro Santana Lopes on Saturday, expressing the wish that "justice will be done" if wrongdoing is proven.

The investigation netting Socrates has also implicated three others who appeared before a judge on Friday, according to the prosecutor.

More than 60 police, customs officers and justice officials carried out raids at several unspecified locations ahead of the arrests.

Socrates' arrest came at a bad time for Lisbon Mayor Antonio Costa, a close ally who was named late Saturday as the main opposition party's secretary general following a ballot in which he was the only candidate.

Costa said in a message to party stalwarts before his election: "We are all certainly in shock over the news (but) we mustn't let personal feelings of solidarity and friendship impede the political action of the (party)."

Portuguese ex-PM Socrates arrested in corruption probe

Portugal's Socialist Party candidate and caretaker Prime Minister Jose Socrates reacts during the general election in Lisbon June 5, 2011.

CREDIT: REUTERS/HUGO CORREIA

(Reuters) - Portuguese police have arrested former Socialist prime minister Jose Socrates and three other people in an investigation of suspected tax fraud, corruption and money-laundering, the Prosecutor General's office said on Saturday.

The detention, the first involving a former premier in Portugalunder democracy, follows arrests of other high-ranking officials or prominent people in separate inquiries in the past few months as prosecutors intensify a fight against corruption in a country notorious for its slow justice system.

Socrates was brought before a criminal judge for questioning on Saturday afternoon after his apartment was searched. The prosecutor's office said the questioning and search were part of an investigation of suspicious banking operations and money transfers, but would not reveal more details.

It was not clear if the investigation was linked to Socrates' time as prime minister between 2005 and 2011.

Police arrested Socrates, 57, at Lisbon airport late on Friday as he arrived from Paris. He spent the night in a police station, according to a police official. The other three arrested individuals are linked to Socrates.

Socrates resigned as prime minister in the middle of his second four-year term in 2011 as an escalating debt crisis forced him to request an international bailout, which imposed painful austerity on Portugal.

His center-left Socialist party leads in opinion polls ahead of next year's general election.

Socialist leader Antonio Costa told party militants in a message that "we are all certainly shocked" with the detention, but added that "feelings of solidarity and personal friendship" should not influence the party's policy or interfere in any way with the independence of the investigation.

"The party has to focus on mobilizing Portugal in affirming an alternative to this government and its policy," he wrote.

A snap election in 2011 brought to power the current center-right ruling coalition, which introduced the unpopular austerity measures such as tax hikes and cuts in wages and pensions.

After stepping down, Socrates left for Paris, where he attended a university course. He returned in 2013 to become a regular commentator on RTP state television.

During his premiership, Socrates weathered several investigations, including allegations that he misused his position as environment minister in 2002 to allow the construction of a shopping mall. He denied wrongdoing and faced no formal charges.

Prosecutors have detained and are investigating several prominent people in separate corruption and fraud cases.

Last week, the head of Portugal's immigration service, Manuel Palos, was arrested along with several other officials on suspicions of corruption linked to the issuing of so-called "golden visas" to wealthy foreign investors. The inquiry also forced Interior Minister Miguel Macedo to resign.

(Editing by Stephen Powell)

FILED UNDER:

WORLDhttp://www.reuters.com/news/world